What really happened yesterday in the House of Lords and what does it mean for home
On one level, a private member’s bill put forward by Lord Soley had its Second Reading.
Lord Soley’s bill is not a government bill.
As I explained in previous blogs, this type of bill doesn’t make it into law, but for someone who feels strongly, it is a way for an issue to be aired.
While it is being debated though, it is generally talked about as though it could conceivably become law.
Lord Soley’s bill will trundle on for a while. There’ll be committee stage some time after Christmas where any member of the house of lords can put forward amendments; peers who spoke yesterday indicated that there were quite a lot of things they wanted to add to the bill or to take out of the bill.
And then on a whole other level there is the reaction of the government to the broader issues raised by the bill.
At Second Reading there will be a Minister responding to the bill and he or she might say the government takes the matter very seriously and is already doing xyz or that such and such a thing is already in the pipeline and will bring about improvements.
Essentially that is what happened with the previous private member’s bill debated yesterday
Alternatively Ministers might opt for saying they will ask someone to review the matter or look at issuing new guidance.
The latter is what happened with the home education bill. LINK
What yesterday means for home educators is that Lord Soley’s bill has pushed the Department for Education into making a statement about new guidelines.
(For completeness I would add that I’m aware of an alternative interpretation namely that the Government was itching to do something about home education and welcomed Lord Soley’s bill as a pretext)
As I have said, Lord Soley will carry on with his bill, but the real action will be over the proposed new government guidelines where Lord Soley has no direct influence since he doesn’t hold a government post.
In respect of these new guidelines, the Minister said that local authorities need to be able to act, but he also added that the Government thinks local authorities “already have the tools for the job.”
We don’t know what will be in the new guidelines nor when we might see a published draft. All the Minister said yesterday was that there would be a public consultation. The government has a consultation website where you can search by department and obviously as soon as I get wind of anything I will post it.
Lord Soley has therefore won some attention from the Government in response to his bill but from where he stands in wanting the law to be changed, he has also lost, since he ends by saying he fears the Minister “may be holding back too much on what the Government could do”. LINK
Current Government Elective Home Education Guidelines are here
In subsequent blog posts I will be looking at the role of Hampshire and Kent in assisting Lord Soley, and also the parliamentary written questions tabled by members of the House of Lords, as well as potential amendments to the home education bill in committee.
Been scouring everywhere to find information on this bill. So glad to come across this, thanks for calming some of my worries. As I’m not on Facebook I’ve not been able to find much. I’ve been home educating for nearly 10 years and reading the proposed bill horrified me. I have a great point of contact at the LA for HE but she is there for help and advice and has never forced herself on my family, nor have I had to register my younger children. I will continue to follow you to watch for updates.
Basically it’s the guidelines now rather than the bill. Although Lord Soley will carry on briefing people about how significant his input is I guess.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the update and explanation Fiona
there were all kinds of undercurrents, but I wanted to zero in on the main story
Thank you Fiona. I have been worrying. Your guarantee this bill is not going to make law has settled me.
the question of how much influence it would have has been resolved sooner rather than later
Thank you for keeping us updated. Let’s continue in hope, believing things will turn out positive rather than negative with all this! Standing strong united.
I wouldn’t be pessimistic but it’s best to cover for all eventualities.
Pingback: Home Education Bill: Helpful Hampshire and Kent | edyourself
Great work as always Fiona – very much appreciated. Thank you
Aww thank you!
Thank you for the information and such clear insight. This is my first visit and I’m super impressed. You come highly recommended by my local HE Group.
Thank you, I’m working on a couple of follow up blog posts out in the next few days.
You are incorrect. A Private Members’ Bill, if it passes through the necessary stages in both Houses, can become an Act of Parliament just like any other law. There have been some famous examples of Private Members’ Bills becomes law – including the Murder (Abolition of Death Penalty) Act 1965 and the Abortion Act 1967. They often do not become Acts of Parliament because they are not given sufficient parliamentary time, but this is very different from saying that these Bills do not make it into law. They most definitely can.
Pingback: Children Not In School – House of Lords May-June 2022 | edyourself